Why Autoplay Adds to Energy Demand

environmental impact of video autoplay

Worried about the environmental impact of video autoplay? It adds to energy demand by streaming clips you never chose, and streaming video is over 1% of greenhouse gas emissions. Turning it off is a sensible small step.

This guide sits within our wider look at the carbon footprint of social media, and it zooms in on one feature: clips that start on their own.

Item Value
Video streaming’s share of consumer data demand about 80%
Streaming video’s share of greenhouse gas emissions (The Shift Project, 2019) over 1%
Estimated share in a September 2021 project post 1.2% to 1.4%
Share of a phone’s energy use that occurs in manufacture about 90%
Suggested minimum time to keep a phone three years or more

These figures come from a Canadian research council evidence brief and a researcher’s project post. Estimates like these can change as new studies appear, so check the source before you rely on them.

What autoplay changes about energy use

Autoplay starts a video before you ask for it. Every clip that plays is video streaming, and the researchers behind our sources count the whole chain: devices, networks, and data centres including storage.

One honest limit: the research we draw on does not measure autoplay on its own. It does cover video embedded in social media and websites, which is where autoplay shows up, so the findings apply by extension rather than by direct measurement.

That matters for how you read any claim about a single feature. If you want a comparison with plain text, our guide to the carbon footprint of a text message covers that side of the picture.

How large is video’s share of emissions?

The Canadian brief describes video streaming as a major part of the energy used by information and communication technology, about 80% of consumer data demand. It includes video on demand, video embedded in social media and websites, video calls and games in that group.

In 2019, the French think tank The Shift Project calculated that streaming video contributes over 1% of the greenhouse gases that cause global warming. The brief’s authors surveyed 22 studies of ICT electricity use and seven studies of streaming video, and they corroborate that over-1% figure.

A September 2021 post from the same research project puts the estimate at 1.2% to 1.4% and rising fast, citing Sandvine 2020 and pandemic-era habits. Treat that as an estimate from one team at one point in time.

Why the numbers disagree

The authors say the disparity between figures in the literature is enormous. Much of it comes from where each study draws the system boundary, meaning what counts as part of streaming. The brief lists the points of dispute:

  • devices, such as phones, tablets, laptops and smart televisions
  • data centres and servers
  • production of equipment and mining of metals
  • disposal of old equipment

The authors also note that many sources reuse earlier figures without cross-checking them. That lets errors carry from one paper to the next.

Why design choices matter: the rebound effect

The brief says streaming video epitomizes the rebound effect, where better energy efficiency leads to greater consumption of a resource. Streaming one video uses less electricity than driving to a video store. But easy online video has created new consumption patterns, driven by addictive design, which the authors say cancel out those savings.

Autoplay is a design choice of that kind, though the sources do not name it. Our reading is that when the next clip starts without a decision from you, more video gets watched, and demand for networks and data centres rises with it.

Resolution shows how much settings can matter. The researchers report that video calls use less electricity per minute than streaming video, but only because some providers impose low resolution and a slow frame rate. They warn that bigger, sharper “immersive” calls could erase that gap.

environmental impact of video autoplay Projected video
Two people sit facing a large projected image in a dark room.

Where the energy goes beyond your screen

Turning off autoplay will not switch off a data centre tonight. The brief states that networks and data centres consume electricity regardless of consumer activity. It adds that curbing consumer demand can help slow the expansion of infrastructure.

Part of that infrastructure is built for worst cases. The authors point to redundancy, the doubling of power supplies for data centres and networks in anticipation of spikes in demand, as one foundation of ICT’s disproportionate carbon footprint. Streaming without lag at peak times is the kind of worst case that systems are built to avoid.

Your phone adds another layer. Mobile devices are energy efficient in use, yet the brief says about 90% of a phone’s energy consumption occurs in its manufacture. Autoplay does not change that, but it is one reason the authors recommend keeping a phone for three years or more.

What you can do about autoplay

The brief lists individual best practices for streaming in general. They fit autoplay well:

  1. Stream less.
  2. Stream at lower resolution.
  3. Watch physical media and TV instead of streaming.
  4. Keep your phone for three years or more.

In practice, that means switching autoplay off wherever an app or site gives you the setting, and picking a lower playback quality when you do choose to watch. Those changes are small, but they are the ones within your control.

For a longer list of habits that go beyond autoplay, see our guide on how to reduce social media carbon footprint.

The researchers also argue that individual choices are not enough. They suggest regulators require streaming platforms to default to standard or low resolution, putting the onus on the viewer to increase resolution.

Frequently asked questions

Does turning off autoplay cut emissions?

Show answer

Probably by a small amount, because less video gets streamed, but the sources do not measure autoplay directly. They do say that curbing consumer demand can help slow the growth of infrastructure.

How much of internet use is video?

Show answer

The Canadian brief puts video streaming at about 80% of consumer data demand. That covers video on demand, social media and website video, video calls and games.

Does lower resolution really help?

Show answer

The brief recommends it as an individual best practice. It also notes that video calls use less electricity per minute than streaming video only because providers impose low resolution and a slow frame rate.

Why do estimates of streaming’s footprint differ?

Show answer

Studies draw the system boundary in different places, for example whether devices, data centres, production, disposal and metal mining are included. The authors also found that many papers reuse earlier figures without cross-checking.

Is my phone a bigger issue than autoplay?

Show answer

For manufacturing, yes. The brief says about 90% of a phone’s energy consumption occurs in its manufacture, which is why it advises keeping a phone for three years or more.